AI Video / News

Seven AI video models, one prompt: what we got for $8

We gave the same short text to Seedance, Kling, Veo, Grok Imagine, Hailuo, Wan and HeyGen. Seven video clips, $8 in total. What each one cost, and which ones did what we asked.

Seven stills of milk being poured into a latte in a café, one from each AI video model, with prices from $0.15 for HeyGen Video to $2.32 for Seedance 2.5
Stills from AI-generated video: the middle picture of each clip from our test of 4 October 2026, with what OpenRouter charged us.

Some AI models turn text into video. You type one sentence, called a prompt, and you get back a short film. You pay per clip. But which model should you use, and what does a clip cost? We gave the same prompt to seven AI video models on the same evening. All seven clips together cost $8. Two models did what we asked very closely. Three jumped to a different shot halfway through. One gave us a sharper picture than we asked for. And one added sound, even though we had switched sound off.

How we tested

Diagram of our test in three steps: one prompt, seven models through OpenRouter's video API with one try each, then measuring the files
Diagram by Not an AI App: how we tested.

We used OpenRouter's video API. With it you can reach many video models with one account and one kind of request. You send a job, check until it is done, and then download the video file (an MP4). The owner of this site paid for the clips with his own OpenRouter credit.

Every model got exactly the same prompt:

We chose it because it mixes things video models often find hard. Think of hands, pouring milk, a pattern that slowly appears, rain on glass and one exact camera move. We asked for 10 seconds, in a wide 16:9 shape, at 720p (a normal HD picture size), with sound. If a model did not offer that, we took the closest choice. Veo 3.1 Fast makes at most 8 seconds. Hailuo 3 Max and HeyGen Video offer 768p. For Hailuo we switched sound off, because OpenRouter's list showed no sound for it.

The seven models were Seedance 2.5 (ByteDance), Kling 3.0 Pro (Kuaishou), Veo 3.1 Fast (Google), Grok Imagine Video 1.5 (xAI), Hailuo 3 Max (MiniMax), Wan 3.0 (Alibaba) and HeyGen Video. HeyGen says its model is "built on MiniMax H3". Kling's update notes say Kling 4.0 is already out. But it was not on OpenRouter's list, so we tested 3.0. We left out Sora 2 Pro, the most expensive choice on the list.

Each model got one try. Video models give a different result every time. So a second try with the same prompt can look quite different.

What did each clip cost?

Bar chart of cost per clip: Seedance 2.5 $2.32, Kling 3.0 Pro $1.68, Grok Imagine Video 1.5 $1.40, Wan 3.0 $0.85, Veo 3.1 Fast and Hailuo 3 Max $0.80, HeyGen Video $0.15
Chart by Not an AI App from OpenRouter's job records. We checked waiting times every 15 seconds, so they are rounded up.

OpenRouter tells you the cost of each finished job. Together the seven clips cost $8.00:

ModelClipChargedWaiting time
Seedance 2.510 s$2.32246 s
Kling 3.0 Pro10 s$1.68293 s
Grok Imagine Video 1.510 s$1.4079 s
Wan 3.010 s$0.85261 s
Veo 3.1 Fast8 s$0.8080 s
Hailuo 3 Max10 s$0.8033 s
HeyGen Video10 s$0.1519 s

Two prices were lower than OpenRouter's own list. HeyGen Video's list price at 768p is $0.03 per second. That would make $0.30. HeyGen's own page mentions a launch price of half the normal price through October. That would explain the $0.15 we paid.

Wan 3.0 is listed at $0.10 per second at 720p. That would make $1.00, but we paid $0.85. Alibaba's price page mentions a discount for a short time. We cannot say if that explains this exact amount.

The waiting time is what our script measured, from sending the job to getting it back. It checked every 15 seconds. So the real times can be up to 15 seconds shorter.

Kling 3.0 and Seedance 2.5: one shot without cuts, as we asked

Two strips of ten stills each: in the Kling and Seedance clips milk is poured, a leaf pattern appears and the camera moves back to a rainy window with bicycles
Stills from AI-generated video, one picture per second: Kling 3.0 Pro and Seedance 2.5.
Kling 3.0 Pro: our test clip AI-generated video from our test of 4 October 2026, exactly as the model sent it back: same café prompt, 10 seconds, $1.68 through OpenRouter.
Seedance 2.5: our test clip AI-generated video from our test of 4 October 2026, exactly as the model sent it back: same café prompt, 10 seconds, $2.32 through OpenRouter.

Two models did what the prompt said in one shot, without any cuts. The milk is poured and the leaf pattern appears. Then the camera moves back until you see the rainy window and the bicycles.

Kling 3.0 Pro comes closest to the prompt. You can see that in the strip of stills in this section. The leaf pattern appears step by step. The camera moves back smoothly. It ends on a barista by the window, with a cyclist riding past outside.

Seedance 2.5 also keeps one shot without cuts. But its first second is strange. The milk is poured into black coffee without any foam. The latte only appears after that. The move back to the window works, with bicycles in the background. It was also the most expensive clip in our test.

We judged this by watching the clips and from stills taken every second. We did not measure picture quality with technical tools. And with one try per model, a different random start could change the picture.

Veo 3.1 Fast and Grok Imagine: smooth, but the latte was already done

Two strips of stills: in the Veo and Grok Imagine clips the leaf pattern is finished from the first picture, then the camera moves towards the window
Stills from AI-generated video, one picture per second: Veo 3.1 Fast (8 seconds) and Grok Imagine Video 1.5.
Veo 3.1 Fast: our test clip AI-generated video from our test of 4 October 2026, exactly as the model sent it back: same café prompt, 8 seconds, $0.80 through OpenRouter.
Grok Imagine Video 1.5: our test clip AI-generated video from our test of 4 October 2026, exactly as the model sent it back: same café prompt, 10 seconds, $1.40 through OpenRouter.

Veo 3.1 Fast made a pretty, steady shot. It moves from the cup to the window, where cyclists with umbrellas ride past. It also added croissants on the counter. But the leaf pattern is already finished in the very first picture. So the part of our prompt where the leaf slowly appears is missing. Veo makes at most 8 seconds, so this clip is two seconds shorter than the others.

Grok Imagine Video 1.5 also starts with a finished pattern. The milk keeps pouring for about six seconds, but the pattern hardly changes. Then the camera swings to the window and the bicycles. The movement is smooth. But the camera moves sideways, not backwards as we asked.

Both clips work fine as mood shots. But if the action itself matters, such as in a video that shows a product, they did worse than Kling and Seedance in our test.

Hailuo, Wan and HeyGen: cuts instead of a camera move

Three strips of stills: Hailuo cuts to a new shot after about four seconds, Wan fades into a new shot, HeyGen cuts three times and ends with cyclists outside
Stills from AI-generated video, one picture per second: Hailuo 3 Max, Wan 3.0 and HeyGen Video.
Hailuo 3 Max: our test clip AI-generated video from our test of 4 October 2026, exactly as the model sent it back: same café prompt, 10 seconds, $0.80 through OpenRouter.
Wan 3.0: our test clip AI-generated video from our test of 4 October 2026, exactly as the model sent it back: same café prompt, 10 seconds, $0.85 through OpenRouter.
HeyGen Video: our test clip AI-generated video from our test of 4 October 2026, exactly as the model sent it back: same café prompt, 10 seconds, $0.15 through OpenRouter.

Three models did not move the camera back slowly. Instead, they jumped to a new shot. We found this by comparing pictures every 0.2 seconds. A sudden big change between two pictures means a cut.

  • Hailuo 3 Max cuts after 4.6 seconds. It jumps from the close-up to a wide shot of a table by the window. The pouring stops when the pattern is only half done.
  • Wan 3.0 fades from the close-up into a new shot at about 4.5 seconds. For a moment you see both pictures at once, one on top of the other. Then the cup stands alone on a counter in front of the window, with cyclists outside.
  • HeyGen Video cuts three times. At 4 seconds it jumps to a closer view of the cup. At about 8.4 seconds it shows a barista behind the counter. At 9 seconds it shows cyclists outside. It feels more like a short edited film than one single shot.

That does not have to be a problem. Sometimes a mix of short shots is exactly what you want. But it is not what we asked for, and you have less control over the result. HeyGen was also by far the cheapest and fastest. That may make up for it if you need lots of short clips.

Did we get what we asked for? Not always

Table comparing what we asked for with what came back: Kling sent 1920 by 1080 instead of 720p, Hailuo included sound although we asked for none
Measured by us on the downloaded files: length, picture size, sound and cuts.

We also checked the video files themselves. Two models gave us something different from what we asked for:

  • Kling 3.0 Pro sent back a video of 1920 × 1080 pixels (Full HD), although we asked for 720p. That fits the price we paid. $1.68 for 10 seconds matches the price for 1080p with sound: $0.168 per second on Kling's own price list. On OpenRouter this model is listed as 720p only. So if you pick it, expect Full HD and the matching price.
  • Hailuo 3 Max sent a clip with sound, although we had switched sound off. We measured how loud the sound was. It was clearly not silent.

All seven clips had stereo sound. We did not judge the sound itself, such as whether the rain and café sounds fit the picture.

Who may use the clips, and how are they marked?

Table of marks and usage rights per model, from the makers' documents: Veo uses an invisible SynthID mark, Kling allows business use
Diagram by Not an AI App from the makers' own pages, as read on 4 October 2026. Not legal advice.

For OpenRouter, the rules say that "your ownership rights in the Output are set forth in the Model Terms for each Model you use". In other words: the rules of each model decide who owns your clip. This is what we found on the makers' own pages on 4 October 2026:

  • Veo (Google): Google's Veo documents say videos are "watermarked using SynthID". That is a mark you cannot see. Google's Gemini API terms say Google "won't claim ownership" of what you make.
  • Kling: the rules for paid users say business use of what you make "is not restricted".
  • Wan (Alibaba): the Model Studio rules say Alibaba does not claim to own what you make. They ask users to mark it as AI-generated where the law requires that.
  • Seedance: you can choose to add a mark in the corner that says a video is AI-generated. We did not find rules about business use just for Seedance.
  • Hailuo (MiniMax): MiniMax's rules ask users to mark what they make clearly. We did not find a clear rule about business use.
  • HeyGen and Grok Imagine: we did not check their rules for this article.

None of our seven clips had a mark you could see. In the EU, rules on marking AI-generated video are getting stricter. So if you publish a clip like this, the safe choice is to say clearly that it is AI-generated. This summary is not legal advice. Read the rules of the model you use.

Questions people ask

List of questions people ask Google about this topic, with the 3 questions we answer marked
"People also ask" questions from Google (US), 9 October 2026, via DataForSEO. Chart by Not an AI App.

Which AI model is best for video generation?

In our test, Kling 3.0 Pro came closest to what we asked, with Seedance 2.5 just behind. Both made one smooth shot without cuts. We gave seven models the same prompt once each on 4 October 2026, so this is a snapshot, not a ranking. HeyGen Video was by far the cheapest and fastest, but it cut between shots.

Is Veo 3 AI free?

Not in our test. Through OpenRouter, one 8 second clip from Veo 3.1 Fast cost us $0.80 on 4 October 2026. We tested Veo 3.1 Fast, not Veo 3. We did not check if Google offers free use anywhere.

Is there a 100% free AI video generator?

We did not test free tools, so we cannot say. All seven models in our test cost money per clip. The cheapest was HeyGen Video at $0.15 for 10 seconds, thanks to a launch discount. The most expensive was Seedance 2.5 at $2.32.

How we checked

Four steps: the same prompt for seven models, every request logged, length, size and sound measured, and stills compared to find cuts.
How we tested the seven video models on 4 October 2026. Diagram by Not an AI App.

We made the seven clips on 4 October 2026 through OpenRouter's video API. Each model got one try, with the prompt shown above. Our script saved every request, its status, the cost OpenRouter reported and the waiting time. Then we opened the downloaded files in Chrome. We measured the length, picture size and sound. We took one still per second, and compared pictures every 0.2 seconds to find cuts. What we wrote about each clip is based on those stills and on watching the clips.

The videos in this article are the files exactly as the models sent them back. The stills are pictures from those videos, made smaller but not edited. Both are AI-generated and marked that way. We made the charts and tables ourselves from our test records. The facts about prices, rights and marks come from the makers' own pages, as read on 4 October 2026: Kling, Google, Alibaba, ByteDance, MiniMax and HeyGen.

One try per model with one prompt is a snapshot, not a ranking. A different prompt or a second try could change the order. And prices and models change quickly.

Update, 19 October 2026: we added our own diagram to a section that did not have an image yet. It shows what this article already says. No facts changed.